Related Posts
Podcasts
You’ve put time and money into your website. You’re getting traffic. But the leads? They’re just not coming in. It’s frustrating—especially when you’ve done everything by the book. Maybe you’ve redesigned your site, improved its speed, and even invested in ads to drive visitors. Yet, for some reason, those visitors aren’t turning into customers. So, what’s going wrong?
The answer isn’t always obvious, and that’s exactly what makes it so frustrating. But in this guide, you’ll learn:
- The most common hidden reasons why websites fail to generate leads
- How to diagnose and fix these problems step by step
- What recent updates from Google mean for your website’s performance
By the end, you’ll know exactly what’s holding your website back—and, more importantly, how to fix it.
Why Your Website Isn’t Generating Leads
If your website isn’t bringing in leads, there’s a reason—it’s just not always easy to spot. Many businesses assume that slow traffic, a bad design, or technical issues are to blame, but often, the real problem runs deeper.
Here are some of the most common reasons why your website might be underperforming:
1. Your Messaging Isn’t Clear
When visitors land on your website, they should instantly understand:
- What you offer
- Who it’s for
- Why it matters to them
If your homepage or landing pages are cluttered, vague, or packed with jargon, visitors may leave before they even figure out what you do.
You can fix this by utilising the Storybrand approach.
Read: What is Storybrand and How Telling Your Story Clearer Can Generate More Revenue
2. Weak or Missing Calls to Action (CTAs)
A surprising number of websites fail to guide visitors toward the next step. If your CTAs are weak, buried in text, or missing entirely, visitors won’t know what to do next—so they’ll leave.
Quick Fix: Make sure every important page has a strong, visible CTA that tells visitors exactly what to do, whether it’s:
- “Get a Free Quote”
- “Download the Guide”
- “Schedule a Consultation”
One way you can do that is by adding your CTA to the top right hand side of your nav bar, like the below page:
3. Visitors Don’t See a Clear Next Step
Even if you have CTAs, they need to align with where visitors are in their buying journey. If someone is visiting your site for the first time, they may not be ready to book a call or buy—so a softer offer, like downloading a free resource, might work better.
Quick Fix: Offer multiple engagement options, such as:
- A free guide or checklist
- A webinar sign-up
- A quiz or interactive tool
In the image above you can see we have three offers on the front page:
- Contact us
- View Pricing
- View All Services
Each offer targets a customer in a different part of the buying journey.
4. Your Website Isn’t Optimised for Trust
People buy from businesses they trust. If your website doesn’t instantly establish credibility, visitors may hesitate to take action.
Quick Fix: Build trust by adding:
- Customer testimonials or case studies
- Trust badges (like certifications or media mentions)
- A real About page that highlights your expertise
- Blog articles that answer your customer’s biggest questions and frustrations
These are some of the most common hidden issues that can keep your website from generating leads. But there’s another major factor that many businesses overlook—one that’s become even more important with Google’s latest updates.
How to Fix the Problem with a Content-First Approach
If your website isn’t generating leads, your content is likely part of the problem. But this isn’t just about writing more blog posts—it’s about creating the right kind of content that both engages visitors and moves them toward taking action.
Google’s Helpful Content Update reinforces this. Websites with vague, generic, or low-value content are now struggling to rank, while those that genuinely help users are performing better.
If your content doesn’t clearly answer questions, solve problems, or guide visitors toward a decision, your site won’t just lose rankings—it will lose potential leads.
So how do you fix this?
1. Make Your Content Visitor-Focused, Not Business-Focused
Many companies create content that talks about themselves—their products, their history, their achievements.
But visitors don’t care about you. They care about how you can help them.
Fix:
- Shift your messaging from “We do X” to “Here’s how you benefit”
- Write in a way that directly speaks to your audience’s pain points and needs
Example Before (Business-Focused):
“We provide high-quality accounting services with 20 years of experience.”
Example After (Visitor-Focused):
“Struggling with tax season? Learn how to make filing simple and stress-free.”
2. Optimise Key Pages for Lead Generation
Your homepage, service pages, and blog posts should all be designed to convert visitors into leads. If they don’t have clear CTAs or compelling content, people won’t take action.
Fix:
- Ensure every important page has a clear CTA (e.g., “Schedule a Free Consultation”)
- Use engaging subheadings and bullet points to make content easy to scan
- Add lead magnets (like free guides or webinars) to capture visitor emails
3. Update Your Blog Strategy: Quality Over Quantity
Publishing lots of blog posts won’t help if they aren’t useful. A few high-quality, problem-solving articles will outperform dozens of generic posts.
Fix:
- Focus on topics that your audience actually searches for (use tools like AnswerThePublic).
- Structure posts for easy readability (short paragraphs, subheadings, bullet points)
- Make sure every post leads to a next step (like signing up for a free resource or booking a call)
4. Align Your Content With Google’s Helpful Content Update
Google’s update prioritises content that is:
- Written for people, not search engines (avoid keyword stuffing)
- Comprehensive and helpful (answer questions fully, provide real value)
- Created by experts (demonstrate knowledge and authority)
Fix:
- Audit your existing content and remove or improve any weak pages
- Ensure blog posts answer questions fully and clearly—don’t leave visitors needing to search elsewhere
- Use real examples, case studies, or expert insights to build credibility
Read: How to Write Blog Articles that Rank & Generate Leads
So, What’s Next?
Your website can generate more leads and sales—you just need the right approach. By shifting to a content-first strategy, you ensure that every visitor gets a clear, helpful, and engaging experience that guides them toward taking action.
Next, read our article on how to build a Learning Centre on your website that converts.
